I am writing this on a flight to Hyderabad.
Thank goodness this is a short flight cos I have a terribly badly behaved child in the seat behind me.I would have been quite happy to put up with a cranky child under five. It's difficult to soothe them when they are in a strange environment and I get it.
What I don't get is why parents would allow a child of about 6 or 7 to behave the way he was behaving.
It started with him yelling in a nagging voice about something. The mother firmly asked him why he was yelling and could he not speak normally. He quietened immediately. I was relieved - although I later realised it was too premature to have assumed that the flight was going to be a peaceful one
As the flight started he started saying "Aaaaaaaaa" in a loud voice allowing his voice to warble with every bump on the runway. As the flight took off, so did his voice.. He hit a shrill high note which stopped abruptly. I wondered if something had happened to him when he reassured me of his existence by rhythmically kicking the back of my seat while he demanded for something to eat.
The mother dropped his tray table down and started unpacking some food. He started slamming the tray table up and down. I turned and said "ma'am could you please ask him not to slam the tray table so hard?"
The mum was completely unapologetic and said "OK" and told him something in Telugu. I understood enough of the language to understand that he was asking what I would do if he didn't stop
I hoped his mum would tell him something sufficiently horrifying. But before she could answer him, another baby wailed loudly from the front of the plane. This boy decided he would mimic the baby and started yelling "aaaaaah" for every "woahhhhh" the baby made. Baby goes "woaahhh" boy goes "aaaah - baby goes "woahhh" boy goes "aaaah"
I stifled my laughter for I did feel more exasperation than amusement. But the gentleman in the seat across wasn't amused in the slightest. He turned and glared at the boy and even through the man's shield and mask the boy could make out the unspoken threat I guess. He piped down. But not for long. He started slamming the tray table again and snorting and making spitting noises. I wondered if he had a developmental issue but it didn't appear so as he was quite clear in the way he communicated with his mum when he wanted water or wanted food.
So I assumed it was just an astonishing display of bad behaviour which his mum ignored. In between, the bad behaviour would escalate into a tantrum and the mum continued to ignore it. I wonder if this was her coping strategy? I have always held that ignoring bad behaviour - be it in adults or in children, never got us good results. But for this mum hope was a strategy I guess!!
I felt something poke my hand and I turned to find the brat grinning at me through the gap in the seat. I'm usually a sucker for kids and would have smiled back but I had had enough of this kid's bad behaviour so I smiled briefly (which he couldn't make out cos of my mask) and turned back.
The man across turned again and glared long and hard at the boy. The boy immediately turned to look out the window and started singing rhymes and thumping the window, an occasional kick delivered to the back of my seat to punctuate an important part of the line in the rhyme
When he stuck his leg through the gap in the armrest and kicked me, I grabbed his leg by the shoe and firmly lifted his leg and put it back. I could hear him complaining to his mum and I really hoped she wasn't going to say something to me cos I was fast losing patience.
The lights came on and he gave a big yell making me nearly jump out of my skin. I realised he was cheering that the flight was landing and I silently cheered as well.
Honestly, there was no way I would have, as a six year old gotten away with such behaviour. Forget everything else, if I'd kicked some stranger with my shoe, my parents would have made me apologise and of course I'd have gotten a whack for sure.
But we live in different times. And discipline isn't exerted in the same way. Children are different. Parents are busy.
All I can say is I don't understand how such behaviour is acceptable and I can only thank my stars that this was a short flight !!

Hmm..
ReplyDeleteI feel that Children are the same.
Parenting differs.
It was a movie in front of my eyes and I could picture the scene as I read through. Yes it's a difficult situation tolerating kids throwing tantrums but as a special needs teaching assistant and a trainee counsellor I'm beginning to think if the child has Autistic Spectrum or ADHD. My nephew (cousin's son) has ASD and I can empathise this story with my cousin. She goes through so much with the boy (8 now) and barely leaves home because of his behaviour. He is otherwise a lovely boy, but with uncontrollable tantrums. Sadly, we don't know their life.
ReplyDeleteYes which is why i held on to my temper and didnt complain to the flight attendant. :) but i also wonder if we are guilty of labelling bad behaviour as a develpmental disorder ...speaking to my friend who is a child psychologist and asking her to do a live on parenting on facebook
DeleteSo well articulated Anu Hasan๐๐. I was clenching my fist as I was reading..raring to whack that kid๐. Love kids myself but bad behaviour in public by kids only has to do with poor parenting.
DeleteOn a lighter note, since it is behind you now, Look at it this way...But for that torturous 1 hour...you got material to write ๐๐!!!
Sunny side up sis !!!
And keep 'em.coming.
well I didnt feel animosity towards the kid but a kind of exasperation with the parent - i mean either you engage with your child and prevent bad behaviour or if you have a development issue, you tell passengers that your child has an issue and i am sure passengers will be more understanding. Doing neither was really what bothered me
DeleteThat one elaborate account of a harrowing experience of a child acting out. I am sure you would have had my daughter for company empathizing with your situation on the flight. We had a similar conversation yesterday when we had gone for a family lunch to one of the luxury hotels in Chennai. Children were running around the lobby and making a racket and the parents did not seem to care. While in some cases what you mention of hope being a coping strategy might be the case, your take that 'ignoring bad behaviour - be it in adults or in children, never got us good results' is absolutely true.
ReplyDeleteWish parents did think about this and took the difficult route to regulate their child's behaviour when it does cross the unacceptable threshold. And if there was a genuine reason for not being able to regulate it, then at least inform the co-passenger about the same to see if they can become an ally for the parent(s).
commpletelt agree with you ... ignoring the child and expecting the passengers to understand doesn't seem like a sensible thing to do
DeleteUfffff! I was loosing my temper while reading each line that you had written and I am wondering how you managed to be there in the whole scene... I would say more than the child his mother should be blamed to allow the child to behave badly n ignoring things happening in front of her... She can ignor but why should a stranger tolerate this yaar...
ReplyDeleteexactly - in fact the only reason i did not complain was this niggling doubt that maybe the kid had some developmental issue. he seemed quite lucid and communicative so i wasnt too sure..
DeleteActually a much needed write up . So well written that I actually can see the whole event unfolding in front of my eyes as though I was travelling in the same flight ... And co-incidentally actor Rahman had a very brief mention on his fb about how he was kept awake throughout the night in his train journey to Indore . This was while travelling for Ponniyin Selvan shoot. I think he put the post 4 days back.
ReplyDeleteWell it's more to do with parenting!!
Along with packing checklist, I wish "the few" also maintained a do's n dont's for their kids while travelling
yes - including (if the child was a special needs child) telling the passengers that they need to be a bit more patient - cos if she had even acknowledged that the child was making it difficult for everyone, people would have been a bit less exasperated
DeleteI have faced a similar situation long before. That too from a kid who was from a family friend of a close family member in the middle of a trip. I am a person who loves to be with kids. But he was very disrespectful and disobedient which made people get annoyed to the core. He started teasing me and nagging (age gap would be atleast 25 years between both of us), talking without any respect, and I was so hurt by his bad behaviour during the trip. To my surprise, his parents were not at all bothered on the kids behaviour. I somehow managed to express about his behaviour to my family member. He told his friend and after which they started to track down where he goes wrong and started spending time with kids and giving personal attention. What I got to know from that incident was something that I am going to carry for lifetime. When parents don't spend enough time with the kids or when they don't focus on kids when they are small, it's going to be very difficult for them to correct it when the kids start to grow. Behaviour or manners starts from home. Parents are their first influencers. So they have to be very careful and influence good things to their kids.
ReplyDeletetrue - i have seen kids respond very well to firm attention - having said that - i wonder how one deals with it if the kid had special needs ?
DeleteParents are busy!! What's the point being busy now n after a few yrs repent for an unacceptable upbringing .. wudnt that b too late to correct...#midnightgnan
ReplyDeletemidnight gyan indeed :)
DeleteWow! I usually don’t comment in posts that I don’t agree with.
ReplyDeleteI am a speech language pathologist and we see kids of all forms day in and day out. While I counsel the parents about a child’s strengths and weakness, I always say this. I feel this applies to every one is here.
“Everyone has a different operating system. Just because a cluster of us have a particular operating system (so called typically developing) and we all follow it. It doesn’t mean we don’t accept someone whose operating system is different from ours. Again from what you’ve said it might not be clear if that kid is typical or atypical (ASD,ADHD or others) but frankly I can see that our threshold to accepting another human being has reduced drastically.
If the child had shown so much tantrums during that brief time, I feel the mother was well aware of the kids behaviour. She either was too ignorant of her fellow passengers or this trip was more important for her. Either ways we are no one to judge. From next time you see a kid showing tantrums please know that:
1) tantrums are sometimes the only way a kid gets to express their emotions. And for a child who has communication difficulty that could literally be their only communication sometimes. So it is important for them if not for us.
2)instead of writing this blog if you tried connecting with the child, say sing that rhymes along. By kicking your seat, he clearly showed he wanted to engage with you. If you had built that trust in him, we never know you have seen a different kid altogether.
Acceptance is not just the kids and their parents changing for the society, It’s also the society changing for them and then both the parties coming to that middle ground.
such an interesting view - so what i hear you saying is that it is ok for the mother to ignore the kids behaviour but important that a total stranger take the responsibility of engaging with the child :) hmmm i disagree with you because the mother should have explained - especially when the kid kicked me she had the perfect cue to tell me that the kid had special needs would i please not get upset. It is as simple as that..:) THIS is feel is the problem - we do not look at simple solutions that are practical. we look at noble ones that are impossible to sustain by everyone
DeleteI've experienced similar issues while traveling and at my clinic. Children go on a rampage and break stuff and parents smile when they see them doing such stuff
ReplyDeletearggghhh ..that "oh my child is so cute he is breaking your stuff" - certainly not something i appreciate. Happned once. Next time they visited, i child proofed the house before the kid landed so she didn't have anything to damage :)
DeleteI could totally relate to this. In the pretext of better parenting, modern day parents are way too chilled out to even correct basic mistakes of their lovely children. In these events, without second thoughts i tell them on their face they need to better manage their kids, afterall, they are so chilled out they should be able to handle my comment :)
ReplyDeleteso true...i checked with two psychologists and both of them were surprised at the reaction i was getting :) but i dont want to reveal what they said. that is coming out as a video soon !!
DeleteYes ,as your last two lines states we live in different times now and being disciplined is not known to most of this generation kids. They learn everything on their own with the blooming technology which is both good as well as bad and they are uncontrollable..!
ReplyDeletesigh :) a lot that is good and a lot that is bad , right?
DeleteYeah ๐
Deleteit is said 'if there is a problem with a child, treat the mother's.having a difficult child affects the psycology of the mother so much. may be the mother on this scenario is tired of handling this child, she is the mother and imagine the number of times she would have gone thru that embarrassment!
ReplyDeleteit is said 'if there is a problem with a child, treat the mother's.having a difficult child affects the psycology of the mother so much. may be the mother on this scenario is tired of handling this child, she is the mother and imagine the number of times she would have gone thru that embarrassment!
ReplyDeleteI have had similar experiences with full grown adults who snore like a grizzly bear in trains, spoiling the sleep if everyone around.
ReplyDeleteNice pls keep it up we will get energetic at least watching those ideal places you post with your commentary with love
ReplyDelete